top of page

What Are the Four Things Any Good Design Requires?

4 hours ago
5 min read
Concept rendering of a white custom home with a row of white gables, set on a cliff above a waterfall with mountains behind

There are four things that must be right in any design, and they must be in balance. I came to that understanding slowly, over many years of first building houses and then drawing them, and it has guided my work ever since.


The four are function, aesthetics, structure and cost. I think of them as the four corners of design. Everything else a designer cares about fits somewhere inside them. They are not particular to houses. They hold for anything made to be seen and used, from a car to a pen.


What does it mean for a design to be good?


A good design is not the most impressive one. It is the one in which four different kinds of rightness are present at the same time.


Any one of them is easy to reach alone. A house can be made striking if nothing else matters. It can be made inexpensive, or strong, or convenient. The work is in holding all four together, for one particular family, on one particular piece of ground.


Function: how does this family actually live?


Function has three parts. The first is the daily life of the people who will live in the house. The second is how they entertain. The third is their relationship to work.


Consider a family with three children and a fourth on the way. The infant's room belongs close to the owner's suite, so that a mother and father can reach the child easily in the night. Consider the difference between a family that has another couple over for dinner and a family that gathers twenty or thirty people at a time. Those are not the same house.


None of this comes from a checklist. It comes out, in conversation, what is important to a family. They will tell me, if I listen properly. That is why a first meeting runs a good two hours, and why most of it is spent listening.


Aesthetics: what should the house feel like?


For a long time I would have said that a house must be beautiful. I no longer say it that way. A house must have the feel that the people who will live in it desire.


The distinction matters. Beauty in the abstract belongs to no one. A feel belongs to a particular person, and it can be carried by many styles: contemporary, modern, modern farm, even brutalist. Style is the vehicle. It is not the destination.


A house that functions properly but is not pleasant to the eye will be rejected, and rightly so. We live inside what we build, and a home should be worthy of the life that is lived in it.


Structure: what does the drawing ask of the people who build it?


Structure is more than whether a house will stand. It is the structural design together with the way the house is heated, cooled and vented. It is everything the eye passes over and the body depends on.


I came to design from construction, and I have never been able to draw a beam as only a line. A beam has a thickness, a height and a weight, and someone carries it, in the warmth and in the cold. Knowing that produces a kind of respect in the person who draws it. Theory has to answer to reality.


That respect is practical. A designer who understands structure can be deliberate, and can bring down the cost of the materials themselves, from columns and beams to windows and doors, while giving up neither the function of the house nor its feel.


Cost: is the design honest about what it asks?


A house can be functional, loved and structurally sound, and if it costs more than the family has to spend, the design has not succeeded. I hold that to be the designer's responsibility, and not only the client's.


Cost is the fourth corner and a full equal of the other three. It is also what makes the four personal. The same house can be exactly right for one family and wrong for another, purely on budget.


This does not argue against excellence. There is always a market for excellence, and it is where every designer should push. Excellence is simply measured against a real family and a real number.


Why must the four be in balance?


Function, aesthetics and structure are never, in themselves, wrong. A very good version of each can always be provided. The difficulty comes only when one of them is held so high that nothing may be conceded to it. Then cost is the corner that carries the weight.


So balance is a matter of concession: something given up on purpose, so that something else may be kept. The work of design is making those choices in the open, early, with the family whose house it is.


Is this true only of houses?


It applies to the design of everything that is made to be seen. Look at a car. It must function well, it must be pleasing to your eye, it must be sound enough to protect the people inside it, and it must fit what you can spend. Look at a refrigerator and you will find the same four. Look at the pen on your desk. It must write well, it must look and feel right in the hand, it must not break or leak, and it must be worth its price. Take any one of the four away and you would no longer call it a good pen.


The only things that stand outside this are the things no one will ever see. A screw buried beneath drywall mud has no need of aesthetics, because no eye will ever rest on it. But anything that is seen by the human eye, if it is good design, has these four things in balance. A home is the most personal example of it that most families will ever undertake.


Where does a good design begin?


It begins with a conversation that covers all four corners at once. The homes on our projects page were each designed that way, and the about us page says more of how I came to this work.


If you are considering a home of your own in Boise, Eagle, Meridian, Star, elsewhere in the Treasure Valley, or in Idaho's mountain country, you can get started here.


Frequently asked questions


What are the four things a good design requires?


Function, aesthetics, structure and cost, held in balance for the particular family the design is for.


Which of the four matters most?


None of them alone. A design succeeds when all four are right together. When one is held too high and nothing is conceded to it, cost is the one that goes out of balance.


Does a well-designed home have to be beautiful?


It has to have the feel the people living in it desire. That feel can be carried by many styles.


What does structure include in a home design?


The structural design itself, together with how the house is heated, cooled and vented.


Is cost really part of design?


Yes. A home that is functional, loved and sound but costs more than the family can spend has not succeeded as a design. Respecting the budget is the designer's responsibility.

 
 
bottom of page